The Ethics of Ethical Travel

“… each man kills the thing he loves” Oscar Wilde

OH SHIT

It’s complicated

I was all gung-ho to start this blog in order to encourage people to retire early and travel the world. Then I read an article about thousands of Barcelona residents protesting over-tourism because of  its negative effects on their quality of life. It gave me pause.

I watched a couple of documentaries and listened to some ethical travel podcasts to get some perspective. It was very sobering. I’m still digesting what I learned and wanted to share my ruminations with you.

Painting of ship

Brain Stem Impulses

The wanderlust gene

The urge to explore

Humans are explorers. For millennia, humans have sought new lands, new experiences, settling in new places. These days, with cheap flights just a click of a button away, and a “bucket list” of destinations to check off and Instagram photos to emulate, it’s a perfect storm.

Approval-seeking

A recent study concluded that trophy hunters collect their grisly prizes in order to gain status. The killing of a large animal and displaying its stuffed corpse or posing with the carcass for social media is the product of the hunter seeking a higher status in the “tribe.”

Tourists these days are on a different hunt — the perfect portrait in that sun hat and flowing dress. The number of sad sack boyfriends I’ve seen robotically taking their girlfriend’s photos posing in front of a famous landmark is notable.

The end goal of both is the same, though: attention, approval and acceptance.

Couple by the water

A PHOTO TELLS 1,000 WORDS

Unfortunately

Thanks, Instagram

My sister’s friend owns a house on a mountainside in Switzerland. One single beautiful photo taken from their street went viral, and there is now a constant stream of “influencers” trespassing on his front lawn, clamouring to take the exact same photograph. He had to erect a fence to keep them out, after many requests to stop, all of which were ignored.

This phenomenon puts pressure often on locations which do not have the infrastructure to absorb this kind of sudden influx.

 A camera in everyone’s pocket

A 2013 university study suggests that taking pictures outsources the job of remembering. Knowing that you can look at something again later prevents you from fully taking it in and appreciating it in the moment.

I love technology, don’t get me wrong. But an unfortunate offshoot of phone camera advances is at the root of this overtourism problem. Everyone is now a documentarian. Beautiful photos can be taken and shared directly from these magical things, with barely a moment’s thought, immediately and at no cost. Less than 20 years ago, you’d need to carry a camera with film, requiring a wait for the prints, each of which cost money. Everything was slower and more thoughtful.

SOLUTIONS

So what can we do?

Your wallet is a powerful weapon.

  • Use tourism for good.
  • Don’t be that drunken yobbo that ruins a beautiful location with your antics. Respect local cultures and conduct yourself appropriately. (Okay grandma)
  • Do your research.
  • Seek out genuine volunteer opportunities.
  • Be mindful around any tourist opportunities involving animals, particularly wild or exotic ones. The behind-the-scenes would probably horrify you. Examples of this type of activity: petting tigers in Thailand (animals are often drugged), watching elephant soccer games (the training methods are horrific), orangutans performing tricks (their habitats are being destroyed) and swimming with dolphins (the animals are captured in a brutal bloodbath where pods are separated and mothers are slaughtered.)
  • Shop, stay & eat at locally owned businesses.
  • Be mindful of the impacts of accommodation apps like AirBNB which can negatively impact local rental costs.
  • Bring a water bottle with a filter rather than use disposable water bottles. Life Straw is a good brand which gives back to developing countries.
  • Consider whether a cruise ship / resort — which have incredibly wasteful practises — are the best use of your dollar. Think about who owns them, where the money ends up. Often to some offshore tax free haven, and not into the hands of the local people who need it most.
  • Tour outfits like Intrepid and G Adventures hire local guides and support local businesses.
  • Limit your long haul flights.
  • Take local ground transit whenever possible.
  • Stay local vs chain hotel.
  • Travel more slowly – stay in a location for a few weeks rather than a few days and really get to know the area. You’ll save money and have a more authentic experience.
  • Consider smaller towns and cities rather than putting so much pressure on the “honey pot” destinations.
Lake with stand up paddlers

Travel slowly!

Don’t treat your trip like a “to do” list

Stop hopping from city to city! Stop taking a million photos and just appreciate the fact that you are there. Look with your eyes, not through the camera lens. You can find a nicer photo online to share or buy a postcard to frame. Are you there to collect photos like a butterfly collector? What do you do with these photos at the end of your trip?

SOMEONE’S HOME

Don’t forget that your vacation spot is someone’s home.

Unless it’s Venice, where most locals have moved to escape the crowds, you are in someone’s home town.

Slow travel. Consider whether airbnb is the best option. Many ethical travellers are boycotting the platform due to its destructive nature on the local economies it professes to support.

We can’t stop tourism — it’s only going to grow. But we can spread the word and be more mindful in our choices and how we respect other people’s homes. Let’s treat each place as if it were our own, because at the end of the day, we all share this blue marble.

FURTHER READING

Take a deeper dive

Now, I’m not giving you homework or anything (just writing that gave me hives), but if you really want to learn more, here are some articles and videos you can watch. Thanks for coming to my TED talk.

Nomadic Matt’s excellent article on the subject

The Last Tourist documentary (free to watch)

Crowded Out – the story of overtourism (free to watch)

Barcelona protests overtourism

Intrepid Travel & G Adventures, ethical tour companies

More about the impact of Air BNB’s